Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 31 to 60 of 105

Thread: Compression speed benchmark

  1. #31
    Programmer Bulat Ziganshin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Uzbekistan
    Posts
    4,593
    Thanks
    801
    Thanked 698 Times in 378 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Sportman
    Testing decompression is a lot of extra work and time I hope it fit in my busy scedule one day
    does this mean that you perform tests by hand?? i can donate you my own compression testing system which automates all the tasks. it usually occupies my system tonight producing reports like ive citated on first page. in particular, it allows to test decompression/testing speed

    also, can you add more archivers/files to your testing? such as rzm, winrk, 7zip ultra, freearc -max. binary file tests may include office/game installation

    thank yo your testing and nimdamsks PF publication, ive discovered some good algorithms that i dont noticed before

  2. #32
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Bulat Ziganshin
    does this mean that you perform tests by hand?? i can donate you my own compression testing system which automates all the tasks. it usually occupies my system tonight producing reports like ive citated on first page. in particular, it allows to test decompression/testing speed

    also, can you add more archivers/files to your testing? such as rzm, winrk, 7zip ultra, freearc -max. binary file tests may include office/game installation
    The first two tests where total manual after that I created a batch file, but still some programs need manual attention.

    I added rzm to test 5, I thought mcomp compress as winrk?

    For test 5 I created a 2GB file the same type as the files located at http://www.random.org/files/ Every programmer from this forum can quick create a program to bring it down to 268,435,456 bytes after checking the data structure of this file, but what about the compressors:

    Input:
    2,147,483,648 bytes

    Output:

    size bytes, ratio, hh:mm:ss (compressor version level)

    1,144,131,840 bytes 1.88x 00:00:22 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 1)
    1,115,993,932 bytes 1.92x 00:00:20 (thor 0.96 e1)
    0,966,378,509 bytes 2.22x 00:00:21 (tornado 0.3 -1)
    0,937,865,970 bytes 2.29x 00:00:21 (lzturbo 0.92 -11)
    0,890,531,622 bytes 2.41x 00:00:20 (lzturbo 0.92 -12)
    0,872,731,937 bytes 2.46x 00:00:15 (lzop 1.01 -1)
    0,846,510,277 bytes 2.54x 00:00:23 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 2)
    0,763,790,646 bytes 2.81x 00:01:26 (flashzip 0.02)
    0,727,714,154 bytes 2.95x 00:00:30 (brieflz)
    0,712,590,709 bytes 3.01x 00:00:16 (slug 1.1b)
    0,681,380,592 bytes 3.15x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -21)
    0,673,809,280 bytes 3.19x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -22)
    0,661,036,679 bytes 3.25x 00:11:34 (m99 fast)
    0,628,978,092 bytes 3.41x 00:01:04 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 3)
    0,527,935,466 bytes 4.07x 00:00:23 (tornado 0.3 -2)
    0,470,375,740 bytes 4.57x 00:00:25 (thor 0.96 e2)
    0,454,235,442 bytes 4.73x 00:00:28 (tornado 0.3 -4)
    0,433,363,636 bytes 4.96x 00:01:03 (thor 0.96 e4)
    0,421,496,169 bytes 5.09x 00:00:28 (arc 0.4 -m1)
    0,421,495,938 bytes 5.09x 00:00:25 (tornado 0.3 -3)
    0,421,483,103 bytes 5.10x 00:00:48 (rar 3.71 -1)
    0,419,045,760 bytes 5.12x 00:06:50 (sbc 0.97 -m1)
    0,417,063,509 bytes 5.15x 00:00:18 (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    0,417,063,509 bytes 5.15x 00:00:17 (lzturbo 0.92 -41)
    0,411,974,867 bytes 5.21x 00:00:18 (lzturbo 0.92 -52)
    0,411,974,867 bytes 5.21x 00:00:18 (lzturbo 0.92 -51)
    0,410,120,761 bytes 5.24x 00:00:46 (tornado 0.3 -5)
    0,405,678,644 bytes 5.29x 00:00:29 (thor 0.96 e3)
    0,403,471,270 bytes 5.32x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -43)
    0,403,213,291 bytes 5.33x 00:01:05 (flashzip 0.03 1)
    0,401,151,926 bytes 5.35x 00:01:16 (flashzip 0.03 2)
    0,400,575,973 bytes 5.36x 00:01:32 (flashzip 0.03 3)
    0,398,785,284 bytes 5.39x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -53)
    0,398,416,321 bytes 5.39x 00:00:57 (tornado 0.3 -6)
    0,396,752,015 bytes 5.41x 00:01:46 (winturtle 1.6.0b)
    0,391,436,167 bytes 5.49x 00:00:23 (lzturbo 0.92 -44)
    0,387,918,927 bytes 5.54x 00:02:03 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    0,387,252,488 bytes 5.55x 00:00:24 (lzturbo 0.92 -54)
    0,383,971,332 bytes 5.59x 00:01:09 (tornado 0.3 -7)
    0,377,880,380 bytes 5.68x 00:00:32 (lzturbo 0.92 -55)
    0,373,121,231 bytes 5.76x 00:02:59 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    0,372,181,863 bytes 5.77x 00:01:32 (tornado 0.3 -
    0,370,345,712 bytes 5.80x 00:00:47 (lzturbo 0.92 -56)
    0,364,126,296 bytes 5.90x 00:01:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -57)
    0,362,364,817 bytes 5.93x 00:01:55 (rar 3.71 -2)
    0,361,790,294 bytes 5.94x 00:02:20 (tornado 0.3 -9)
    0,357,914,250 bytes 6.00x 00:14:36 (kwc 0.0.3.0)
    0,357,679,586 bytes 6.00x 00:03:06 (7za 4.57 7z 1)
    0,356,279,042 bytes 6.03x 00:01:48 (7za 4.57 zip 1)
    0,356,278,956 bytes 6.03x 00:01:49 (7za 4.57 gzip 1)
    0,355,770,086 bytes 6.04x 00:03:51 (tornado 0.3 -10
    0,355,382,128 bytes 6.04x 00:04:36 (winace 2.69 superfast)
    0,354,479,747 bytes 6.06x 00:02:52 (rar 3.71 -3)
    0,354,190,134 bytes 6.06x 00:03:11 (lzturbo 0.92 -5
    0,352,848,851 bytes 6.09x 00:08:01 (tornado 0.3 -11)
    0,352,350,488 bytes 6.09x 00:04:21 (mcomp 1.0 -d64f)
    0,347,278,310 bytes 6.18x 00:15:19 (tornado 0.3 -12)
    0,345,885,038 bytes 6.21x 00:01:28 (7za 4.57 bzip2 1)
    0,345,833,140 bytes 6.21x 00:05:39 (winace 2.69 fast)
    0,344,604,104 bytes 6.23x 00:08:02 (thor 0.96 e5)
    0,343,814,699 bytes 6.25x 00:02:05 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5)
    0,336,631,828 bytes 6.38x 00:10:39 (winace 2.69 normal)
    0,336,262,020 bytes 6.39x 00:05:45 (mcomp 1.0 -ff)
    0,335,971,946 bytes 6.39x 00:05:55 (mcomp 1.0 -f3f)
    0,331,294,772 bytes 6.48x 00:15:45 (winace 2.69 good)
    0,325,062,559 bytes 6.61x 00:37:44 (lzpm 0.15 1)
    0,323,585,292 bytes 6.64x 00:36:25 (winace 2.69 maximum)
    0,300,730,496 bytes 7.14x 00:12:56 (7za 4.57 zip 5)
    0,300,730,410 bytes 7.14x 00:12:59 (7za 4.57 gzip 5)
    0,290,350,732 bytes 7.40x 00:27:40 (7za 4.57 7z 5)
    0,283,225,786 bytes 7.58x 00:05:07 (arc 0.4 -m6)
    0,282,448,583 bytes 7.60x 00:04:33 (arc 0.4 -m4)
    0,282,285,431 bytes 7.61x 00:05:48 (arc 0.4 -m7)
    0,282,215,107 bytes 7.61x 00:24:34 (rzm 0.07b)
    0,281,978,393 bytes 7.62x 00:04:57 (arc 0.4 -m5)
    0,281,959,886 bytes 7.62x 00:04:21 (arc 0.4 -m3)
    0,274,715,018 bytes 7.82x 00:01:33 (arc 0.4 -m2)
    0,273,968,688 bytes 7.84x 00:03:04 (rar 3.71 -4)
    0,273,596,492 bytes 7.85x 00:02:02 (pim 2.10)
    0,273,401,872 bytes 7.85x 00:03:02 (rar 3.71 -5)
    0,273,229,591 bytes 7.86x 00:01:33 (tarsaLZP)
    0,272,783,939 bytes 7.87x 00:29:36 (paq9a -9)
    0,271,451,333 bytes 7.91x 00:24:03 (rzm 0.06b)
    0,270,666,952 bytes 7.93x 01:04:03 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)
    0,270,413,458 bytes 7.94x 00:15:15 (cmm4 0.0)
    0,270,306,495 bytes 7.94x 00:17:26 (lzxq 0.2)
    0,269,981,519 bytes 7.95x 00:12:08 (sbc 0.97 -m3)
    0,269,970,190 bytes 7.95x 00:08:10 (sbc 0.97 -m2)
    0,269,529,756 bytes 7.97x 01:02:15 (bbb 1280)
    0,269,509,544 bytes 7.97x 00:04:15 (ccm 1.3 0)
    0,269,509,522 bytes 7.97x 00:04:20 (ccmx 1.30 7)
    0,269,464,788 bytes 7.97x 00:23:56 (lpaq1)
    0,269,333,158 bytes 7.97x 00:08:45 (lzturbo 0.92 -59)
    0,269,163,213 bytes 7.98x 00:07:15 (sr3)
    0,269,162,179 bytes 7.98x 00:00:37 (sr2)
    0,268,484,920 bytes 8.00x 00:11:04 (ppmonstr default)
    0,268,435,456 bytes 8.00x 00:00:xx (theory)

    to big input file (rar 3.71 zip fastest)
    to big input file (rar 3.71 zip fast)
    to big input file (rar 3.71 zip normal)
    to big input file (rar 3.71 zip good)
    to big input file (rar 3.71 zip max)
    to big input file (quad 1.12)
    to big input file (quad 1.12 -x)
    to big input file (lpaq8e)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 1)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 2)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 3)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 4)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 5)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 6)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 7)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 9)
    wrong output file size (lzc 0.08 10)
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 55)
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 12
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 256)
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 512)
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 1024)
    wrong output file size (hook 1.3 1280)
    wrong output file size (slim23d)
    skipped to long time (lzop 1.01 -9)
    skipped to long time (cabarc 1.0 default)
    skipped to long time (lzxq 0.2)
    skipped to long time (lzpm 0.15 2)
    skipped to long time (lzpm 0.15 9)
    skipped to long time (lzw 0.2)
    skipped to long time (m99 max)
    skipped to long time (rings v1.2)
    crash (dark 0.51 default)
    crash (durilca light 0.5 default)

  3. #33
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Moscow
    Posts
    239
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 3 Times in 1 Post
    Yes, it's me again Don't kill me if i irritate you

    1) P.F. -> using >=2 CPU cores:
    Code:
    0,872,731,937 bytes 2.46x 00:00:15 (lzop 1.01 -1) 
    0,712,590,709 bytes 3.01x 00:00:16 (slug 1.1b) 
    0,417,063,509 bytes 5.15x 00:00:17 (lzturbo 0.92 -41) 
    0,411,974,867 bytes 5.21x 00:00:18 (lzturbo 0.92 -51) 
    0,398,785,284 bytes 5.39x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -53) 
    0,391,436,167 bytes 5.49x 00:00:23 (lzturbo 0.92 -44) 
    0,387,252,488 bytes 5.55x 00:00:24 (lzturbo 0.92 -54) 
    0,377,880,380 bytes 5.68x 00:00:32 (lzturbo 0.92 -55) 
    0,269,162,179 bytes 7.98x 00:00:37 (sr2) 
    0,268,484,920 bytes 8.00x 00:11:04 (ppmonstr default)
    2) P.F. -> using 1 CPU core:
    Code:
    0,872,731,937 bytes 2.46x 00:00:15 (lzop 1.01 -1) 
    0,712,590,709 bytes 3.01x 00:00:16 (slug 1.1b) 
    0,527,935,466 bytes 4.07x 00:00:23 (tornado 0.3 -2) 
    0,421,495,938 bytes 5.09x 00:00:25 (tornado 0.3 -3) 
    0,405,678,644 bytes 5.29x 00:00:29 (thor 0.96 e3) 
    0,269,162,179 bytes 7.98x 00:00:37 (sr2) 
    0,268,484,920 bytes 8.00x 00:11:04 (ppmonstr default)
    Tables are small today

  4. #34
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by nimdamsk
    Yes, its me again Dont kill me if i irritate you
    I like your P.F. tables

    For test 6 I used the Debian Linux 2.6.24, Apache 2.28, MySQL 5.0.51a, PHP 5.2.5 (LAMP) + Firefox 3.0b4 source code as input (one file made with RAR store), test platform same as test 1 to 5.

    Input file:
    729,287,225 bytes

    Output:

    size bytes, ratio, hh:mm:ss (compressor version level)

    499,773,168 bytes 1.46x 00:00:13 (flashzip 0.02)
    440,064,722 bytes 1.66x 00:05:02 (kwc 0.0.3.0)
    285,171,103 bytes 2.56x 00:00:05 (tornado 0.3 -1)
    275,126,015 bytes 2.65x 00:00:02 (quicklz 1.30 -1)
    272,965,585 bytes 2.67x 00:00:24 (lzc 0.08 1)
    269,339,777 bytes 2.71x 00:00:22 (lzc 0.08 2)
    268,256,248 bytes 2.72x 00:00:04 (lzop 1.01 -1)
    266,909,779 bytes 2.73x 00:00:22 (lzc 0.08 3)
    264,853,652 bytes 2.75x 00:00:23 (lzc 0.08 4)
    262,811,241 bytes 2.77x 00:00:25 (lzc 0.08 5)
    260,077,045 bytes 2.80x 00:00:30 (lzc 0.08 6)
    258,555,964 bytes 2.82x 00:01:09 (lzc 0.08 10)
    258,001,995 bytes 2.83x 00:00:55 (lzc 0.08 9)
    257,994,877 bytes 2.83x 00:00:37 (lzc 0.08 7)
    256,390,823 bytes 2.84x 00:00:44 (lzc 0.08
    255,863,035 bytes 2.85x 00:00:07 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 1)
    255,516,810 bytes 2.85x 00:00:03 (thor 0.96 e1)
    253,635,344 bytes 2.88x 00:00:02 (quicklz 1.30 -0)
    251,787,532 bytes 2.90x 00:00:09 (brieflz)
    251,548,634 bytes 2.90x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.30 -2)
    242,080,866 bytes 3.01x 00:04:10 (lzw 0.2)
    241,125,918 bytes 3.02x 00:00:03 (slug 1.1b)
    239,399,730 bytes 3.05x 00:00:02 (lzturbo 0.92 -11)
    228,720,602 bytes 3.19x 00:00:06 (tornado 0.3 -2)
    227,844,842 bytes 3.20x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 2)
    227,642,088 bytes 3.20x 00:00:05 (thor 0.96 e2)
    226,863,414 bytes 3.21x 00:00:13 (rar 3.71 zip fastest)
    226,863,327 bytes 3.21x 00:00:11 (gzip 1.3.12 -1)
    226,111,556 bytes 3.23x 00:00:09 (quicklz 1.30 -3)
    223,684,234 bytes 3.26x 00:00:02 (lzturbo 0.92 -21)
    219,954,902 bytes 3.32x 00:00:19 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 1)
    219,954,815 bytes 3.32x 00:00:19 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 1)
    219,411,533 bytes 3.32x 00:00:17 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 3)
    217,592,083 bytes 3.35x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -12)
    214,385,166 bytes 3.40x 00:00:49 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 lza)
    213,314,373 bytes 3.42x 00:00:16 (rar 3.71 zip fast)
    211,821,157 bytes 3.44x 00:01:34 (lzop 1.01 -9)
    205,513,465 bytes 3.55x 00:00:07 (arc 0.4 -m1)
    205,513,234 bytes 3.55x 00:00:07 (tornado 0.3 -3)
    204,039,539 bytes 3.57x 00:00:05 (lzturbo 0.92 -13)
    199,695,798 bytes 3.65x 00:00:15 (rar 3.71 -1)
    199,356,707 bytes 3.66x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -22)
    199,046,096 bytes 3.66x 00:00:06 (thor 0.96 e3)
    198,883,996 bytes 3.67x 00:00:19 (7za 4.57 zip 1)
    198,883,909 bytes 3.67x 00:00:19 (7za 4.57 gzip 1)
    197,405,963 bytes 3.69x 00:00:08 (lzturbo 0.92 -51)
    197,004,453 bytes 3.70x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -41)
    195,679,126 bytes 3.73x 00:00:08 (tornado 0.3 -4)
    194,608,891 bytes 3.75x 00:00:44 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 16)
    193,170,634 bytes 3.78x 00:00:29 (rar 3.71 zip normal)
    192,825,190 bytes 3.78x 00:00:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -52)
    192,373,575 bytes 3.79x 00:00:56 (cabarc 1.0 default)
    192,023,963 bytes 3.80x 00:00:49 (rar 3.71 zip good)
    192,015,045 bytes 3.80x 00:00:44 (gzip 1.3.12 -9)
    191,945,712 bytes 3.80x 00:01:03 (rar 3.71 zip max)
    190,620,855 bytes 3.83x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    188,294,399 bytes 3.87x 00:00:42 (mcomp 1.0 -d64f)
    187,451,342 bytes 3.89x 00:01:18 (7za 4.57 zip 5)
    187,451,255 bytes 3.89x 00:01:18 (7za 4.57 gzip 5)
    187,247,095 bytes 3.89x 00:01:09 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 1)
    187,195,891 bytes 3.90x 00:00:24 (7za 4.57 bzip2 1)
    186,465,044 bytes 3.91x 00:00:17 (thor 0.96 e5)
    186,272,329 bytes 3.92x 00:04:11 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 15)
    186,272,242 bytes 3.92x 00:03:56 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 15)
    181,651,491 bytes 4.01x 00:00:23 (sr2)
    180,905,775 bytes 4.03x 00:00:12 (lzturbo 0.92 -53)
    180,259,282 bytes 4.05x 00:00:37 (7za 4.57 7z 1)
    179,671,357 bytes 4.06x 00:02:53 (lzxq 0.2)
    178,756,649 bytes 4.08x 00:00:06 (lzturbo 0.92 -43)
    177,077,502 bytes 4.12x 00:00:16 (lzturbo 0.92 -54)
    176,747,046 bytes 4.13x 00:00:17 (tornado 0.3 -5)
    175,513,884 bytes 4.16x 00:00:30 (sr3)
    175,352,022 bytes 4.16x 00:00:16 (flashzip 0.03 1)
    174,835,743 bytes 4.17x 00:00:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -44)
    174,515,872 bytes 4.18x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -55)
    172,913,914 bytes 4.22x 00:00:21 (tornado 0.3 -6)
    172,788,806 bytes 4.22x 00:00:24 (lzturbo 0.92 -56)
    171,962,784 bytes 4.24x 00:00:13 (thor 0.96 e4)
    171,653,289 bytes 4.25x 00:00:31 (lzturbo 0.92 -57)
    170,447,589 bytes 4.28x 00:00:19 (flashzip 0.03 2)
    170,447,300 bytes 4.28x 00:00:59 (lzturbo 0.92 -5
    169,169,732 bytes 4.31x 00:01:01 (hook 1.3 55)
    167,089,999 bytes 4.36x 00:00:24 (flashzip 0.03 3)
    166,197,297 bytes 4.39x 00:00:29 (tornado 0.3 -7)
    165,788,353 bytes 4.40x 00:00:58 (tarsaLZP)
    164,804,950 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5)
    164,803,226 bytes 4.43x 00:01:18 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 9)
    164,715,786 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    164,500,065 bytes 4.43x 00:01:52 (winace 2.69 superfast)
    164,061,829 bytes 4.45x 00:01:55 (winace 2.69 fast)
    163,369,686 bytes 4.46x 00:00:46 (flashzip 0.03 5)
    163,067,899 bytes 4.47x 00:01:33 (m99 fast)
    162,888,445 bytes 4.48x 00:00:40 (tornado 0.3 -
    162,593,982 bytes 4.49x 00:00:40 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 30)
    162,533,389 bytes 4.49x 00:02:15 (winace 2.69 normal)
    162,371,585 bytes 4.49x 00:02:18 (winace 2.69 good)
    162,265,193 bytes 4.49x 00:02:21 (winace 2.69 maximum)
    161,394,504 bytes 4.52x 00:01:01 (rar 3.71 -2)
    161,316,322 bytes 4.52x 00:01:17 (lzpm 0.15 1)
    161,041,398 bytes 4.53x 00:01:34 (hook 1.3 12
    159,685,318 bytes 4.57x 00:00:41 (rings v1.2)
    159,223,744 bytes 4.58x 00:00:51 (quad 1.12)
    158,896,084 bytes 4.59x 00:01:06 (tornado 0.3 -9)
    158,464,366 bytes 4.60x 00:01:23 (rar 3.71 -3)
    157,972,354 bytes 4.62x 00:01:44 (hook 1.3 256)
    157,949,835 bytes 4.62x 00:01:50 (tornado 0.3 -10)
    157,168,150 bytes 4.64x 00:03:41 (tornado 0.3 -11)
    156,729,680 bytes 4.65x 00:06:50 (tornado 0.3 -12)
    156,445,322 bytes 4.66x 00:02:15 (m99 max)
    156,185,652 bytes 4.67x 00:01:49 (lzturbo 0.92 -59)
    155,962,317 bytes 4.68x 00:02:53 (lzpm 0.15 2)
    155,728,154 bytes 4.68x 00:01:12 (sbc 0.97 -m1)
    155,363,152 bytes 4.69x 00:01:55 (hook 1.3 512)
    154,784,787 bytes 4.71x 00:01:55 (quad 1.12 -x)
    154,336,708 bytes 4.73x 00:01:30 (dark 0.51 default)
    153,692,064 bytes 4.75x 00:01:29 (sbc 0.97 -m2)
    153,345,796 bytes 4.76x 00:02:10 (hook 1.3 1024)
    153,180,594 bytes 4.76x 00:02:32 (hook 1.3 1280)
    151,455,524 bytes 4.82x 00:00:47 (arc 0.4 -m2)
    151,170,031 bytes 4.82x 00:02:48 (sbc 0.97 -m3)
    150,915,805 bytes 4.83x 00:01:58 (mcomp 1.0 -ff)
    150,481,902 bytes 4.85x 00:01:25 (rar 3.71 -4)
    149,283,442 bytes 4.89x 00:13:21 (lzpm 0.15 9)
    148,130,385 bytes 4.92x 00:02:27 (mcomp 1.0 -f3f)
    146,988,597 bytes 4.96x 00:41:17 (bbb 1280)
    146,977,759 bytes 4.96x 00:01:36 (rar 3.71 -5)
    146,745,620 bytes 4.97x 00:02:18 (7za 4.57 7z 5)
    144,817,435 bytes 5.04x 00:03:30 (durilca light 0.5 default)
    144,454,688 bytes 5.05x 00:01:49 (arc 0.4 -m3)
    143,576,516 bytes 5.08x 00:02:50 (pim 2.10)
    142,486,151 bytes 5.12x 00:02:04 (arc 0.4 -m4)
    140,900,194 bytes 5.18x 00:03:19 (7za 4.57 7z 9)
    140,272,617 bytes 5.20x 00:02:18 (arc 0.4 -m5)
    138,578,255 bytes 5.26x 00:02:41 (arc 0.4 -m7)
    138,516,118 bytes 5.26x 00:02:29 (arc 0.4 -m6)
    136,471,099 bytes 5.34x 00:06:25 (rzm 0.06b)
    135,557,429 bytes 5.38x 00:07:12 (rzm 0.07b)
    133,416,473 bytes 5.47x 00:02:30 (ccm 1.3 0)
    133,023,500 bytes 5.48x 00:03:03 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    127,239,812 bytes 5.73x 00:02:47 (ccm 1.3 7)
    127,036,299 bytes 5.74x 00:44:25 (slim23d)
    125,143,752 bytes 5.83x 00:16:01 (ppmonstr default)
    124,780,400 bytes 5.84x 00:03:36 (ccmx 1.3 7)
    121,594,062 bytes 6.00x 00:12:04 (lpaq1)
    120,789,779 bytes 6.04x 00:20:33 (arc 0.4 -m7 -max)
    120,191,192 bytes 6.07x 00:11:45 (paq9a -9)
    117,812,729 bytes 6.19x 00:11:38 (lpaq8e)
    117,351,110 bytes 6.21x 00:12:13 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)

    wrong output file size (winturtle 1.6.0b)
    crash (cmm4 0.0)

  5. #35
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Moscow
    Posts
    239
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 3 Times in 1 Post
    1) P.F. -> including optimized for >=2 CPU cores:
    Code:
    223,684,234 bytes 3.26x 00:00:02 (lzturbo 0.92 -21) 
    190,620,855 bytes 3.83x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -42) 
    178,756,649 bytes 4.08x 00:00:06 (lzturbo 0.92 -43) 
    174,835,743 bytes 4.17x 00:00:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -44) 
    171,962,784 bytes 4.24x 00:00:13 (thor 0.96 e4) 
    170,447,589 bytes 4.28x 00:00:19 (flashzip 0.03 2) 
    167,089,999 bytes 4.36x 00:00:24 (flashzip 0.03 3) 
    166,197,297 bytes 4.39x 00:00:29 (tornado 0.3 -7) 
    164,715,786 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (flashzip 0.03 4) 
    162,593,982 bytes 4.49x 00:00:40 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 30) 
    159,685,318 bytes 4.57x 00:00:41 (rings v1.2) 
    151,455,524 bytes 4.82x 00:00:47 (arc 0.4 -m2) 
    150,481,902 bytes 4.85x 00:01:25 (rar 3.71 -4) 
    146,977,759 bytes 4.96x 00:01:36 (rar 3.71 -5) 
    144,454,688 bytes 5.05x 00:01:49 (arc 0.4 -m3) 
    142,486,151 bytes 5.12x 00:02:04 (arc 0.4 -m4) 
    140,272,617 bytes 5.20x 00:02:18 (arc 0.4 -m5) 
    138,516,118 bytes 5.26x 00:02:29 (arc 0.4 -m6) 
    133,416,473 bytes 5.47x 00:02:30 (ccm 1.3 0) 
    127,239,812 bytes 5.73x 00:02:47 (ccm 1.3 7) 
    124,780,400 bytes 5.84x 00:03:36 (ccmx 1.3 7) 
    117,812,729 bytes 6.19x 00:11:38 (lpaq8e) 
    117,351,110 bytes 6.21x 00:12:13 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)
    2) P.F. -> using 1 CPU core only (not sure about Stuffit):
    Code:
    253,635,344 bytes 2.88x 00:00:02 (quicklz 1.30 -0) 
    241,125,918 bytes 3.02x 00:00:03 (slug 1.1b) 
    227,642,088 bytes 3.20x 00:00:05 (thor 0.96 e2) 
    199,046,096 bytes 3.66x 00:00:06 (thor 0.96 e3) 
    195,679,126 bytes 3.73x 00:00:08 (tornado 0.3 -4) 
    171,962,784 bytes 4.24x 00:00:13 (thor 0.96 e4) 
    170,447,589 bytes 4.28x 00:00:19 (flashzip 0.03 2) 
    167,089,999 bytes 4.36x 00:00:24 (flashzip 0.03 3) 
    166,197,297 bytes 4.39x 00:00:29 (tornado 0.3 -7) 
    164,715,786 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (flashzip 0.03 4) 
    162,593,982 bytes 4.49x 00:00:40 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 30) 
    159,685,318 bytes 4.57x 00:00:41 (rings v1.2) 
    151,455,524 bytes 4.82x 00:00:47 (arc 0.4 -m2) 
    150,481,902 bytes 4.85x 00:01:25 (rar 3.71 -4) 
    146,977,759 bytes 4.96x 00:01:36 (rar 3.71 -5) 
    144,454,688 bytes 5.05x 00:01:49 (arc 0.4 -m3) 
    142,486,151 bytes 5.12x 00:02:04 (arc 0.4 -m4) 
    140,272,617 bytes 5.20x 00:02:18 (arc 0.4 -m5) 
    138,516,118 bytes 5.26x 00:02:29 (arc 0.4 -m6) 
    133,416,473 bytes 5.47x 00:02:30 (ccm 1.3 0) 
    127,239,812 bytes 5.73x 00:02:47 (ccm 1.3 7) 
    124,780,400 bytes 5.84x 00:03:36 (ccmx 1.3 7) 
    117,812,729 bytes 6.19x 00:11:38 (lpaq8e) 
    117,351,110 bytes 6.21x 00:12:13 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)
    Code:
    191,945,712 bytes 3.80x 00:01:03 (rar 3.71 zip max) 
    190,620,855 bytes 3.83x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    Awesome result!

  6. #36
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    I added a single 1TB SATA disk (49-101MB/s, 8-13ms) to the test platform and repeated test 6 (only batch file archivers) at this harddisk (read and write) to see the difference with the 3 x 32GB SSD RAID0 (275MB/s-291MB/s, 0.1ms) used in the first test.

    Input file:
    729,287,225 bytes

    Output:

    size bytes, ratio, hh:mm:ss (compressor version level)

    499,773,168 bytes 1.46x 00:00:13 (flashzip 0.02)
    285,171,103 bytes 2.56x 00:00:06 (tornado 0.3 -1)
    275,126,015 bytes 2.65x 00:00:02 (quicklz 1.30 -1)
    272,965,585 bytes 2.67x 00:00:24 (lzc 0.08 1)
    269,339,777 bytes 2.71x 00:00:22 (lzc 0.08 2)
    268,256,248 bytes 2.72x 00:00:05 (lzop 1.01 -1)
    266,909,779 bytes 2.73x 00:00:22 (lzc 0.08 3)
    264,853,652 bytes 2.75x 00:00:23 (lzc 0.08 4)
    262,811,241 bytes 2.77x 00:00:25 (lzc 0.08 5)
    260,077,045 bytes 2.80x 00:00:30 (lzc 0.08 6)
    258,555,964 bytes 2.82x 00:01:05 (lzc 0.08 10)
    258,001,995 bytes 2.83x 00:00:54 (lzc 0.08 9)
    257,994,877 bytes 2.83x 00:00:36 (lzc 0.08 7)
    256,390,823 bytes 2.84x 00:00:44 (lzc 0.08
    255,863,035 bytes 2.85x 00:00:03 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 1)
    255,516,810 bytes 2.85x 00:00:03 (thor 0.96 e1)
    253,635,344 bytes 2.88x 00:00:09 (quicklz 1.30 -0)
    251,787,532 bytes 2.90x 00:00:09 (brieflz)
    251,548,634 bytes 2.90x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.30 -2)
    242,080,866 bytes 3.01x 00:04:10 (lzw 0.2)
    241,125,918 bytes 3.02x 00:00:03 (slug 1.1b)
    239,399,730 bytes 3.05x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -11)
    228,720,602 bytes 3.19x 00:00:07 (tornado 0.3 -2)
    227,844,842 bytes 3.20x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 2)
    227,642,088 bytes 3.20x 00:00:05 (thor 0.96 e2)
    226,863,327 bytes 3.21x 00:00:11 (gzip 1.3.12 -1)
    226,111,556 bytes 3.23x 00:00:09 (quicklz 1.30 -3)
    223,684,234 bytes 3.26x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -21)
    219,411,533 bytes 3.32x 00:00:17 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 3)
    217,592,083 bytes 3.35x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -12)
    211,821,157 bytes 3.44x 00:01:34 (lzop 1.01 -9)
    205,513,465 bytes 3.55x 00:00:08 (arc 0.4 -m1)
    205,513,234 bytes 3.55x 00:00:07 (tornado 0.3 -3)
    204,039,539 bytes 3.57x 00:00:06 (lzturbo 0.92 -13)
    199,695,798 bytes 3.65x 00:00:15 (rar 3.71 -1)
    199,356,707 bytes 3.66x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -22)
    199,046,096 bytes 3.66x 00:00:06 (thor 0.96 e3)
    198,883,996 bytes 3.67x 00:00:20 (7za 4.57 zip 1)
    198,883,909 bytes 3.67x 00:00:18 (7za 4.57 gzip 1)
    197,405,963 bytes 3.69x 00:00:08 (lzturbo 0.92 -51)
    197,004,453 bytes 3.70x 00:00:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -41)
    195,679,126 bytes 3.73x 00:00:10 (tornado 0.3 -4)
    192,825,190 bytes 3.78x 00:00:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -52)
    192,373,563 bytes 3.79x 00:00:56 (cabarc 1.0 default)
    192,015,045 bytes 3.80x 00:00:44 (gzip 1.3.12 -9)
    190,620,855 bytes 3.83x 00:00:04 (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    188,294,399 bytes 3.87x 00:00:42 (mcomp 1.0 -d64f)
    187,451,342 bytes 3.89x 00:01:19 (7za 4.57 zip 5)
    187,451,255 bytes 3.89x 00:01:18 (7za 4.57 gzip 5)
    187,195,891 bytes 3.90x 00:00:23 (7za 4.57 bzip2 1)
    186,465,044 bytes 3.91x 00:00:17 (thor 0.96 e5)
    181,651,491 bytes 4.01x 00:00:22 (sr2)
    180,905,775 bytes 4.03x 00:00:13 (lzturbo 0.92 -53)
    180,259,282 bytes 4.05x 00:00:38 (7za 4.57 7z 1)
    179,671,357 bytes 4.06x 00:02:53 (lzxq 0.2)
    178,756,649 bytes 4.08x 00:00:07 (lzturbo 0.92 -43)
    177,077,502 bytes 4.12x 00:00:17 (lzturbo 0.92 -54)
    176,747,046 bytes 4.13x 00:00:16 (tornado 0.3 -5)
    175,513,884 bytes 4.16x 00:00:30 (sr3)
    175,352,022 bytes 4.16x 00:00:16 (flashzip 0.03 1)
    174,835,743 bytes 4.17x 00:00:10 (lzturbo 0.92 -44)
    174,515,872 bytes 4.18x 00:00:19 (lzturbo 0.92 -55)
    172,913,914 bytes 4.22x 00:00:22 (tornado 0.3 -6)
    172,788,806 bytes 4.22x 00:00:24 (lzturbo 0.92 -56)
    171,962,784 bytes 4.24x 00:00:13 (thor 0.96 e4)
    171,653,289 bytes 4.25x 00:00:30 (lzturbo 0.92 -57)
    170,447,589 bytes 4.28x 00:00:19 (flashzip 0.03 2)
    170,447,300 bytes 4.28x 00:00:59 (lzturbo 0.92 -5
    169,169,732 bytes 4.31x 00:01:01 (hook 1.3 55)
    167,089,999 bytes 4.36x 00:00:24 (flashzip 0.03 3)
    166,197,297 bytes 4.39x 00:00:30 (tornado 0.3 -7)
    165,788,353 bytes 4.40x 00:00:58 (tarsaLZP)
    164,804,950 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5)
    164,715,786 bytes 4.43x 00:00:32 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    163,369,686 bytes 4.46x 00:00:46 (flashzip 0.03 5)
    163,067,899 bytes 4.47x 00:01:34 (m99 fast)
    162,888,445 bytes 4.48x 00:00:42 (tornado 0.3 -
    161,394,504 bytes 4.52x 00:01:00 (rar 3.71 -2)
    161,316,322 bytes 4.52x 00:01:17 (lzpm 0.15 1)
    161,041,398 bytes 4.53x 00:01:33 (hook 1.3 12
    159,685,318 bytes 4.57x 00:00:42 (rings v1.2)
    159,223,744 bytes 4.58x 00:00:56 (quad 1.12)
    158,896,084 bytes 4.59x 00:01:07 (tornado 0.3 -9)
    158,464,366 bytes 4.60x 00:01:23 (rar 3.71 -3)
    157,972,354 bytes 4.62x 00:01:43 (hook 1.3 256)
    157,949,835 bytes 4.62x 00:01:46 (tornado 0.3 -10)
    157,168,150 bytes 4.64x 00:03:43 (tornado 0.3 -11)
    156,729,680 bytes 4.65x 00:07:22 (tornado 0.3 -12)
    156,445,322 bytes 4.66x 00:02:15 (m99 max)
    156,185,652 bytes 4.67x 00:01:49 (lzturbo 0.92 -59)
    155,962,317 bytes 4.68x 00:02:53 (lzpm 0.15 2)
    155,728,154 bytes 4.68x 00:01:12 (sbc 0.97 -m1)
    155,363,152 bytes 4.69x 00:01:54 (hook 1.3 512)
    154,784,787 bytes 4.71x 00:01:55 (quad 1.12 -x)
    154,336,708 bytes 4.73x 00:01:31 (dark 0.51 default)
    153,692,064 bytes 4.75x 00:01:30 (sbc 0.97 -m2)
    153,345,796 bytes 4.76x 00:02:10 (hook 1.3 1024)
    153,180,594 bytes 4.76x 00:02:33 (hook 1.3 1280)
    151,455,524 bytes 4.82x 00:00:48 (arc 0.4 -m2)
    151,170,031 bytes 4.82x 00:02:49 (sbc 0.97 -m3)
    150,915,805 bytes 4.83x 00:01:58 (mcomp 1.0 -ff)
    150,481,902 bytes 4.85x 00:01:26 (rar 3.71 -4)
    149,283,442 bytes 4.89x 00:13:34 (lzpm 0.15 9)
    148,130,385 bytes 4.92x 00:02:27 (mcomp 1.0 -f3f)
    146,988,597 bytes 4.96x 00:41:21 (bbb 1280)
    146,977,759 bytes 4.96x 00:01:36 (rar 3.71 -5)
    146,745,620 bytes 4.97x 00:02:18 (7za 4.57 7z 5)
    144,817,435 bytes 5.04x 00:03:33 (durilca light 0.5 default)
    144,454,688 bytes 5.05x 00:01:49 (arc 0.4 -m3)
    142,486,151 bytes 5.12x 00:02:04 (arc 0.4 -m4)
    140,900,194 bytes 5.18x 00:03:19 (7za 4.57 7z 9)
    140,272,617 bytes 5.20x 00:02:18 (arc 0.4 -m5)
    138,578,255 bytes 5.26x 00:02:41 (arc 0.4 -m7)
    138,516,118 bytes 5.26x 00:02:28 (arc 0.4 -m6)
    136,471,099 bytes 5.34x 00:06:25 (rzm 0.06b)
    135,557,429 bytes 5.38x 00:07:12 (rzm 0.07b)
    133,416,473 bytes 5.47x 00:02:30 (ccm 1.3 0)
    133,023,500 bytes 5.48x 00:03:03 (cmmx 1.3 0)
    127,276,839 bytes 5.73x 00:42:16 (slim23d)
    127,239,812 bytes 5.73x 00:02:46 (ccm 1.3 7)
    125,143,752 bytes 5.83x 00:16:02 (ppmonstr default)
    124,780,400 bytes 5.84x 00:03:35 (cmmx 1.3 7)
    121,594,062 bytes 6.00x 00:12:10 (lpaq1)
    120,789,779 bytes 6.04x 00:20:26 (arc 0.4 -m7 -max)
    120,191,192 bytes 6.07x 00:11:40 (paq9a -9)
    117,812,729 bytes 6.19x 00:11:35 (lpaq8e)
    117,351,110 bytes 6.21x 00:12:07 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)

    crash (cmm4 0.0)

    Strange thing is that slim has 240,540 bytes difference with last test and cabarc 12 bytes.

    The speed difference is not much, mostly between 0 and 1 second accept some acceptions.

  7. #37
    Tester
    Nania Francesco's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Italy
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks
    234
    Thanked 160 Times in 90 Posts
    Be sorry me that Winturtle 1.60b for the first time in the tests don't is not result reliable! I will resolve the problem in the next version! I wanted to ask if it were possible to make some tests on Flashzip in the options " c x 1 - c x 2... c x 5 " Thanks!

  8. #38
    The Founder encode's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Moscow, Russia
    Posts
    4,023
    Thanks
    415
    Thanked 416 Times in 158 Posts
    How about BALZ? I know it's slow at compression, just interested to see it's compression results on <u>your</u> test set.

  9. #39
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Nania Francesco Antonio
    Be sorry me that Winturtle 1.60b for the first time in the tests dont is not result reliable! I will resolve the problem in the next version! I wanted to ask if it were possible to make some tests on Flashzip in the options " c x 1 - c x 2... c x 5 " Thanks!
    I got with test 6 (SSD) result 729,287,269 bytes 00:00:06 (winturtle 1.6.0) thats bigger then the input file size. I found two bugs in winturtle GUI; there is no scroll bar when there are more files then fitting in window and when you compress two times behind each other a single file the file size of the second file is added to the file size of the first file in the result menu. If I need to test something you can email me a test version.

    This are the results of flashzip x 1-5 at test 6 (SSD):

    172,484,506 bytes 4.23x 00:00:33 (flashzip 0.03 x 1)
    167,392,142 bytes 4.36x 00:00:35 (flashzip 0.03 x 2)
    163,746,395 bytes 4.45x 00:00:47 (flashzip 0.03 x 3)
    161,105,647 bytes 4.53x 00:01:06 (flashzip 0.03 x 4)
    159,578,094 bytes 4.57x 00:01:41 (flashzip 0.03 x 5)

  10. #40
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by encode
    How about BALZ? I know its slow at compression, just interested to see its compression results on your test set.
    Result at test 6 (SSD):

    161,892,834 bytes 4.50x 00:23:20 (balz 1.02)

  11. #41
    The Founder encode's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Moscow, Russia
    Posts
    4,023
    Thanks
    415
    Thanked 416 Times in 158 Posts
    OK, thanks!

  12. #42
    Tester
    Nania Francesco's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Italy
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks
    234
    Thanked 160 Times in 90 Posts
    thanks!

  13. #43
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    For test 7 I used a binary index (one big file) of a much bigger database as input file, test platform same as test 1 to 6 SSD.

    Input file:
    1,066,160,748 bytes

    Output:

    size bytes, ratio, hh:mm:ss (compressor version level)

    798,416,193 bytes 1.34x 00:00:13 (tornado 0.3 -1)
    760,106,029 bytes 1.40x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 1)
    657,759,152 bytes 1.62x 00:00:08 (lzturbo 0.92 -11)
    647,350,194 bytes 1.65x 00:00:16 (brieflz)
    646,550,767 bytes 1.65x 00:00:11 (quicklz 1.30 -0)
    646,296,322 bytes 1.65x 00:00:11 (lzop 1.01 -1)
    634,984,952 bytes 1.68x 00:00:05 (quicklz 1.30 -1)
    613,960,994 bytes 1.74x 00:00:10 (quicklz 1.30 -2)
    610,109,022 bytes 1.75x 00:00:20 (quicklz 1.30 -3)
    609,638,280 bytes 1.75x 00:00:41 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 3)
    596,692,766 bytes 1.79x 00:15:58 (lzw 0.2)
    595,039,732 bytes 1.79x 00:00:06 (thor 0.96 e1)
    593,066,991 bytes 1.80x 00:00:09 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 2)
    576,760,370 bytes 1.85x 00:01:01 (lzc 0.08 1)
    559,042,409 bytes 1.91x 00:01:01 (lzc 0.08 2)
    544,392,500 bytes 1.96x 00:01:11 (lzc 0.08 3)
    542,689,896 bytes 1.96x 00:00:09 (thor 0.96 e2)
    540,868,484 bytes 1.97x 00:08:01 (lzop 1.01 -9)
    540,779,864 bytes 1.97x 00:00:06 (slug 1.1b)
    530,466,302 bytes 2.01x 00:01:37 (lzc 0.08 4)
    525,176,352 bytes 2.03x 00:00:11 (thor 0.96 e3)
    524,918,022 bytes 2.03x 00:00:06 (lzturbo 0.92 -21)
    517,825,828 bytes 2.06x 00:02:50 (lzc 0.08 5)
    515,119,012 bytes 2.07x 00:00:55 (rar zip fast)
    514,122,740 bytes 2.07x 00:01:05 (thor 0.96 e4)
    511,038,710 bytes 2.09x 00:00:45 (7za 4.57 zip 1)
    511,038,623 bytes 2.09x 00:00:44 (7za 4.57 gzip 1)
    510,501,235 bytes 2.09x 00:00:32 (rar zip fastest)
    510,501,148 bytes 2.09x 00:00:28 (gzip 1.3.12 -1)
    505,946,108 bytes 2.11x 00:04:12 (lzc 0.08 6)
    499,983,133 bytes 2.13x 00:00:46 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 1)
    499,983,046 bytes 2.13x 00:00:46 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 1)
    496,374,917 bytes 2.15x 00:06:10 (lzc 0.08 7)
    496,000,586 bytes 2.15x 00:02:27 (rar zip normal)
    495,923,773 bytes 2.15x 00:02:33 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 lha)
    493,790,485 bytes 2.16x 00:00:51 (flashzip 0.03 1)
    493,511,592 bytes 2.16x 00:00:56 (flashzip 0.03 x 1)
    492,963,967 bytes 2.16x 00:01:02 (flashzip 0.03 2)
    492,594,438 bytes 2.16x 00:01:09 (flashzip 0.03 x 2)
    491,946,821 bytes 2.17x 00:06:30 (rar zip good)
    491,895,806 bytes 2.17x 00:06:58 (cabarc 1.0 default)
    491,379,900 bytes 2.17x 00:01:18 (flashzip 0.03 3)
    491,156,079 bytes 2.17x 00:08:25 (rar zip best)
    491,142,562 bytes 2.17x 00:05:31 (gzip 1.3.12 -9)
    491,003,074 bytes 2.17x 00:00:21 (tornado 0.3 -2)
    490,660,067 bytes 2.17x 00:01:33 (flashzip 0.03 x 3)
    489,287,277 bytes 2.18x 00:01:45 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    488,737,655 bytes 2.18x 00:01:48 (mcomp 1.0 -d64f)
    488,433,188 bytes 2.18x 00:08:41 (lzc 0.08
    488,041,105 bytes 2.18x 00:02:13 (flashzip 0.03 x 4)
    487,830,751 bytes 2.19x 00:00:22 (arc 0.4 -m1)
    487,830,518 bytes 2.19x 00:00:22 (tornado 0.3 -3)
    487,584,366 bytes 2.19x 00:00:26 (tornado 0.3 -4)
    487,203,838 bytes 2.19x 00:02:32 (flashzip 0.03 5)
    485,623,960 bytes 2.20x 00:03:27 (flashzip 0.03 x 5)
    484,875,199 bytes 2.20x 00:02:29 (quad 1.12)
    484,565,865 bytes 2.20x 00:03:03 (quad 1.12 -x)
    482,888,372 bytes 2.21x 00:01:10 (thor 0.96 e5)
    481,480,895 bytes 2.21x 00:00:29 (rar 3.71 -1)
    480,675,298 bytes 2.22x 00:00:28 (flashzip 0.02)
    479,891,927 bytes 2.22x 00:11:46 (lzc 0.08 9)
    471,190,465 bytes 2.26x 00:00:49 (arc 0.4 -m2)
    471,190,233 bytes 2.26x 00:00:48 (tornado 0.3 -5)
    470,001,718 bytes 2.27x 00:04:32 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 15)
    470,001,631 bytes 2.27x 00:04:00 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 15)
    469,414,063 bytes 2.27x 00:01:06 (tornado 0.3 -6)
    468,898,885 bytes 2.27x 00:02:00 (7za 4.57 zip 5)
    468,898,798 bytes 2.27x 00:01:59 (7za 4.57 gzip 5)
    467,661,303 bytes 2.28x 00:01:29 (tornado 0.3 -7)
    466,733,161 bytes 2.28x 00:02:13 (tornado 0.3 -
    463,510,268 bytes 2.30x 00:03:25 (tornado 0.3 -9)
    463,168,941 bytes 2.30x 00:05:35 (tornado 0.3 -10)
    462,745,602 bytes 2.30x 00:07:28 (lzpm 0.15 1)
    460,550,718 bytes 2.31x 00:14:27 (lzpm 0.15 2)
    460,451,633 bytes 2.32x 00:10:18 (tornado 0.3 -11)
    460,104,810 bytes 2.32x 00:18:01 (tornado 0.3 -12)
    456,331,005 bytes 2.34x 00:24:49 (lzpm 0.15 9)
    454,612,976 bytes 2.35x 00:02:14 (rar 3.71 -2)
    451,282,185 bytes 2.36x 00:03:25 (winace 2.69 fastest)
    450,183,093 bytes 2.37x 00:03:44 (winace 2.69 fast)
    449,869,289 bytes 2.37x 00:04:52 (winace 2.69 good)
    449,220,473 bytes 2.37x 00:05:02 (winace 2.69 maximum)
    448,759,373 bytes 2.38x 00:04:39 (winace 2.69 normal)
    446,289,131 bytes 2.39x 00:01:05 (uharc 0.6a -mz)
    443,780,174 bytes 2.40x 00:03:11 (rar 3.71 -3)
    442,716,196 bytes 2.41x 00:03:37 (rar 3.71 -4)
    442,008,180 bytes 2.41x 00:04:10 (rar 3.71 -5)
    441,832,579 bytes 2.41x 00:01:33 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 16)
    441,311,862 bytes 2.42x 00:01:50 (winturtle 1.6.0b)
    438,433,851 bytes 2.43x 00:01:33 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 1)
    438,420,202 bytes 2.43x 00:00:31 (7za 4.57 bzip2 1)
    437,861,025 bytes 2.43x 00:00:44 (sr2)
    430,905,817 bytes 2.47x 00:07:11 (lzxq 0.2)
    421,574,900 bytes 2.53x 00:01:07 (sr3)
    420,698,531 bytes 2.53x 00:06:42 (mcomp 1.0 -ff)
    414,471,286 bytes 2.57x 00:02:04 (tarsaLZP)
    412,840,690 bytes 2.58x 00:07:53 (mcomp 1.0 -f3f)
    411,872,231 bytes 2.59x 00:01:31 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 9)
    411,858,117 bytes 2.59x 00:00:45 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5)
    410,536,936 bytes 2.60x 00:02:17 (hook 1.3 55)
    408,780,117 bytes 2.61x 00:03:43 (hook 1.3 12
    407,198,788 bytes 2.62x 00:02:51 (arc 0.4 -m3)
    405,528,657 bytes 2.63x 00:01:35 (7za 4.57 7z 1)
    405,448,779 bytes 2.63x 00:04:17 (hook 1.3 256)
    393,929,407 bytes 2.71x 00:03:15 (sbc 0.97 -m2)
    393,782,777 bytes 2.71x 00:02:44 (sbc 0.97 -m1)
    393,583,778 bytes 2.71x 00:05:48 (sbc 0.97 -m3)
    393,235,087 bytes 2.71x 00:02:32 (m99 fast)
    392,329,700 bytes 2.72x 00:01:32 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 30)
    389,664,022 bytes 2.74x 00:02:07 (dark 0.51 default)
    387,968,393 bytes 2.75x 00:09:00 (pim 2.10)
    386,060,144 bytes 2.76x 00:13:10 (uharc 0.6a -m3)
    385,326,217 bytes 2.77x 00:16:02 (rzm 0.07b)
    379,278,759 bytes 2.81x 00:12:31 (uharc 0.6a -m2)
    379,195,618 bytes 2.81x 00:04:06 (m99 max)
    378,756,812 bytes 2.81x 00:10:05 (uharc 0.6a -m1)
    378,455,510 bytes 2.82x 00:01:46 (rings v1.2)
    378,028,385 bytes 2.82x 00:13:45 (rzm 0.06b)
    373,271,041 bytes 2.86x 00:05:47 (hook 1.3 512)
    372,751,110 bytes 2.86x 00:06:36 (hook 1.3 1280)
    372,515,716 bytes 2.86x 00:06:26 (hook 1.3 1024)
    369,612,033 bytes 2.88x 00:05:44 (ccm 1.3 0)
    369,506,580 bytes 2.89x 00:04:55 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    368,005,193 bytes 2.90x 00:09:20 (durilca light 0.5 default)
    364,764,154 bytes 2.92x 00:15:34 (uharc 0.6a -mx)
    360,700,617 bytes 2.96x 00:12:28 (cmm4 0.0)
    359,893,469 bytes 2.96x 00:05:50 (arc 0.4 -m4)
    359,501,648 bytes 2.97x 00:08:28 (arc 0.4 -m5)
    359,419,656 bytes 2.97x 00:09:57 (arc 0.4 -m6)
    359,286,845 bytes 2.97x 00:11:35 (arc 0.4 -m7)
    357,561,637 bytes 2.98x 00:07:06 (7za 4.57 7z 5)
    356,512,413 bytes 2.99x 00:21:06 (lpaq8e)
    356,458,694 bytes 2.99x 00:10:06 (7za 4.57 7z 9)
    354,739,773 bytes 3.01x 00:19:43 (lpaq1)
    353,657,493 bytes 3.01x 00:05:40 (ccm 1.3 7)
    351,741,964 bytes 3.03x 00:07:00 (ccmx 1.3 7)
    338,113,577 bytes 3.15x 00:21:22 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)
    338,048,368 bytes 3.15x 00:33:59 (paq9a -9)
    330,513,838 bytes 3.23x 00:44:31 (ppmonstr default)
    325,388,437 bytes 3.28x 01:47:52 (slim23d)

    wrong output file size bytes (lzc 0.08 10)
    wrong output file size bytes (arc 0.4 -m7 -max)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -12)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -13)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -41)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -43)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -44)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -51)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -52)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -53)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -54)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -55)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -56)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -57)
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -5
    skipped to long time (lzturbo 0.92 -59)
    skipped to long time (bbb 1280)

  14. #44
    Tester
    Nania Francesco's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Italy
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks
    234
    Thanked 160 Times in 90 Posts
    Thanks! Rings 1.2 Very Impressive!

  15. #45
    Programmer Bulat Ziganshin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Uzbekistan
    Posts
    4,593
    Thanks
    801
    Thanked 698 Times in 378 Posts
    rzm 0.07 has huge progress, and especially on such type of files:

    Creating archive: test using rzm006
    Compressed 1 file, 68.980.736 => 9.319.085 bytes. Ratio 13.5%

    Creating archive: test using rzm007
    Compressed 1 file, 68.980.736 => 8.660.070 bytes. Ratio 12.5%

    can you please test it? (on old filesets too)

  16. #46
    Programmer
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    420
    Thanks
    28
    Thanked 163 Times in 18 Posts
    Thanks for the tests, sportman! Can you please use RZM 0.07e instead of 0.07b. Actually, 0.07b was removed for good a few minutes after its release.
    Btw., if I'm not mistaken, something seems to be wrong with CCM(x)'s ENWIK results.

  17. #47
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Posts
    30
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Sportman
    Thanks very very much for testing!
    - Please can you retest lzturbo (test file 7) with adding option -p1 (
    or -p0 for compression and -p1 for decompression) and see if the problems persist. (I think it's related to the used pthreads-win32 library on windows).
    - Please can you (if it's not too much work for you) make the tests also with options -45 to -4.

    Thanks again.

  18. #48
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Christian
    Btw., if Im not mistaken, something seems to be wrong with CCM(x)s ENWIK results.
    Yes you are right, when I prepaired the results of test 6 I discovered that I wrong labeled ccm 7 as ccmx 7 in test 4 and 5, I tried to change it but the edit option in this forum was already disabled for that old posts.

    Overview ccm and ccmx:

    Test 1:
    296,979,187 bytes 00:07:26 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    294,980,095 bytes 00:05:49 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    216,410,323 bytes 00:06:04 (ccm 1.3 7)
    203,361,296 bytes 00:08:48 (ccmx 1.3 7)

    Test 2:
    287,747,467 bytes 00:06:15 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    287,744,894 bytes 00:05:18 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    234,125,932 bytes 00:06:02 (ccm 1.3 7)
    233,383,870 bytes 00:07:49 (ccmx 1.3 7)

    Test 3:
    63,881,826 bytes 00:05:30 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    61,574,459 bytes 00:06:44 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    58,817,196 bytes 00:05:42 (ccm 1.3 7)
    54,573,912 bytes 00:07:26 (ccmx 1.3 7) listed

    Test 4:
    207,614,970 bytes 00:04:59 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    206,716,896 bytes 00:03:53 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    185,893,165 bytes 00:04:15 (ccm 1.3 7) listed as ccmx
    174,142,092 bytes 00:05:57 (ccmx 1.3 7)

    Test 5:
    269,509,697 bytes 00:05:31 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    269,509,683 bytes 00:05:43 (ccmx 1.3 7)
    269,509,544 bytes 00:04:15 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    269,509,522 bytes 00:04:20 (ccm 1.3 7) listed as ccmx

    Test 6:
    133,416,473 bytes 00:02:30 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    133,023,500 bytes 00:03:03 (ccmx 1.3 0) listed
    127,239,812 bytes 00:02:47 (ccm 1.3 7) listed
    124,780,400 bytes 00:03:36 (ccmx 1.3 7) listed

    Test 7:
    369,612,033 bytes 00:05:44 (ccm 1.3 0) listed
    369,506,580 bytes 00:04:55 (ccmx 1.3 0) listed
    353,657,493 bytes 00:05:40 (ccm 1.3 7) listed
    351,741,964 bytes 00:07:00 (ccmx 1.3 7) listed

  19. #49
    Programmer
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    420
    Thanks
    28
    Thanked 163 Times in 18 Posts
    Thanks again!

  20. #50
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Bulat Ziganshin
    rzm 0.07 has huge progress, and especially on such type of files: can you please test it? (on old filesets too)
    Quote Originally Posted by Christian
    Can you please use RZM 0.07e instead of 0.07b.
    Overview rzm:

    Test 1:
    260,742,352 bytes 00:17:48 (rzm 0.06b)
    258,571,711 bytes 00:19:27 (rzm 0.07e)

    Test 2:
    248,998,685 bytes 00:18:06 (rzm 0.07e)
    245,293,212 bytes 00:15:20 (rzm 0.06b)

    Test 3:
    71,712,252 bytes 00:18:52 (rzm 0.06b)
    67,747,177 bytes 00:21:38 (rzm 0.07e)

    Test 4:
    210,722,103 bytes 00:11:06 (rzm 0.06b)
    210,126,103 bytes 00:12:11 (rzm 0.07e)

    Test 5:
    282,215,107 bytes 00:24:34 (rzm 0.07b) listed
    272,413,184 bytes 00:28:21 (rzm 0.07e)
    271,451,333 bytes 00:24:03 (rzm 0.06b) listed

    Test 6:
    136,471,099 bytes 00:06:25 (rzm 0.06b) listed
    135,557,429 bytes 00:07:12 (rzm 0.07b) listed
    135,556,258 bytes 00:07:22 (rzm 0.07e)

    Test 7:
    385,326,217 bytes 00:16:02 (rzm 0.07b) listed
    378,028,385 bytes 00:13:45 (rzm 0.06b) listed
    372,414,248 bytes 00:17:00 (rzm 0.07e)

  21. #51
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by donotdisturb
    Please can you retest lzturbo (test file 7) with adding option -p1 (
    or -p0 for compression and -p1 for decompression) and see if the problems persist.
    I tested option -12, -41 and -51 with -p0 or -p1 but still the same problem. Yesterday I let run option -12 for more then 9 hours at 4 cores (100% cpu) but still not finished so it looks like an endless loop somewhere.

  22. #52
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Posts
    30
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Thanks Sportman.

  23. #53
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    For test 8 I scanned a full color glossy cover page of a sports magazine with sporting people in action at 2400 dpi, it resulted in one 20,396 x 28,080 pixels 24 bits BMP image file what I used as input.

    Input:
    1,718,159,096 bytes

    Output:

    size bytes, ratio, hh:mm:ss (compressor version level)

    1,614,550,485 bytes 1.06x 00:00:26 (tornado 0.3 -1)
    1,570,506,048 bytes 1.09x 00:02:45 (lzw 0.2)
    1,486,600,287 bytes 1.16x 00:00:18 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 1)
    1,420,836,037 bytes 1.21x 00:00:49 (brieflz)
    1,411,307,409 bytes 1.22x 00:00:18 (quicklz 1.30 -1)
    1,404,693,388 bytes 1.22x 00:00:18 (quicklz 1.30 -0)
    1,395,072,553 bytes 1.23x 00:00:20 (quicklz 1.30 -2)
    1,386,478,989 bytes 1.24x 00:00:21 (lzturbo 0.92 -11)
    1,378,262,582 bytes 1.25x 00:00:20 (lzturbo 0.92 -21)
    1,378,237,829 bytes 1.25x 00:00:25 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 2)
    1,374,753,818 bytes 1.25x 00:00:32 (quicklz 1.30 -3)
    1,353,540,656 bytes 1.27x 00:00:53 (quicklz 1.4.0 b7 3)
    1,326,861,726 bytes 1.29x 00:00:29 (lzop 1.01 -1)
    1,320,460,586 bytes 1.30x 00:00:17 (thor 0.96 e1)
    1,307,213,479 bytes 1.31x 00:00:20 (lzturbo 0.92 -12)
    1,293,258,511 bytes 1.33x 00:00:42 (lzturbo 0.92 -13)
    1,273,721,777 bytes 1.35x 00:03:44 (lzop 1.01 -9)
    1,260,891,010 bytes 1.36x 00:00:19 (slug 1.1b)
    1,239,335,736 bytes 1.39x 00:00:19 (thor 0.96 e2)
    1,234,636,508 bytes 1.39x 00:00:20 (lzturbo 0.92 -41)
    1,228,747,052 bytes 1.40x 00:00:23 (thor 0.96 e3)
    1,225,780,905 bytes 1.40x 00:00:21 (lzturbo 0.92 -22)
    1,211,134,895 bytes 1.42x 00:01:06 (rar zip fastest)
    1,211,134,810 bytes 1.42x 00:00:53 (gzip 1.3.12 -1)
    1,204,424,602 bytes 1.43x 00:01:15 (rar zip fast)
    1,198,332,745 bytes 1.43x 00:02:02 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 lha)
    1,198,305,350 bytes 1.43x 00:00:32 (arc 0.4 -m2)
    1,198,305,350 bytes 1.43x 00:00:32 (arc 0.4 -m1)
    1,198,304,946 bytes 1.43x 00:00:28 (tornado 0.3 -2)
    1,196,716,438 bytes 1.44x 00:01:15 (rar zip normal)
    1,196,391,656 bytes 1.44x 00:01:18 (rar zip good)
    1,196,251,061 bytes 1.44x 00:01:25 (rar zip best)
    1,196,343,267 bytes 1.44x 00:01:08 (gzip 1.3.12 -9)
    1,193,299,194 bytes 1.44x 00:00:32 (tornado 0.3 -3)
    1,192,290,371 bytes 1.44x 00:01:48 (cabarc 1.0 default)
    1,191,311,339 bytes 1.44x 00:01:54 (mcomp 1.0 -d64f)
    1,184,314,166 bytes 1.45x 00:01:03 (7za 4.57 zip 1)
    1,184,314,081 bytes 1.45x 00:01:47 (7za 4.57 gzip 1)
    1,181,912,830 bytes 1.45x 00:00:54 (rar 3.71 -1)
    1,175,383,788 bytes 1.46x 00:01:03 (thor 0.96 e4)
    1,175,111,510 bytes 1.46x 00:00:44 (tornado 0.3 -4)
    1,174,648,966 bytes 1.46x 00:01:20 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 1)
    1,174,648,911 bytes 1.46x 00:01:20 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 1)
    1,174,590,036 bytes 1.46x 00:01:40 (7za 4.57 zip 5)
    1,174,589,951 bytes 1.46x 00:01:39 (7za 4.57 gzip 5)
    1,173,129,160 bytes 1.46x 00:00:55 (thor 0.96 e5)
    1,170,670,336 bytes 1.47x 00:00:23 (lzturbo 0.92 -42)
    1,165,508,221 bytes 1.47x 00:07:11 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 zip 15)
    1,165,508,136 bytes 1.47x 00:07:10 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 gzip 15)
    1,127,295,477 bytes 1.52x 00:01:39 (tornado 0.3 -5)
    1,118,139,024 bytes 1.54x 00:02:18 (tornado 0.3 -6)
    1,106,355,572 bytes 1.55x 00:02:53 (tornado 0.3 -7)
    1,095,642,074 bytes 1.57x 00:00:48 (lzturbo 0.92 -43)
    1,091,923,083 bytes 1.57x 00:03:36 (tornado 0.3 -
    1,077,070,490 bytes 1.60x 00:05:14 (tornado 0.3 -9)
    1,076,176,501 bytes 1.60x 00:01:14 (lzturbo 0.92 -44)
    1,069,923,385 bytes 1.61x 00:01:31 (lzturbo 0.92 -45)
    1,066,417,083 bytes 1.61x 00:04:47 (rar 3.71 -2)
    1,061,834,977 bytes 1.62x 00:01:53 (lzturbo 0.92 -46)
    1,061,452,918 bytes 1.62x 00:08:22 (tornado 0.3 -10)
    1,058,577,568 bytes 1.62x 00:02:30 (lzturbo 0.92 -47)
    1,055,509,336 bytes 1.63x 00:05:55 (lzturbo 0.92 -4
    1,048,343,143 bytes 1.64x 00:03:08 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 16)
    1,044,473,758 bytes 1.64x 00:01:32 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 1)
    1,044,400,932 bytes 1.65x 00:00:46 (7za 4.57 bzip2 1)
    1,043,167,223 bytes 1.65x 00:01:08 (lzturbo 0.92 -52)
    1,042,289,169 bytes 1.65x 00:14:31 (tornado 0.3 -11)
    1,040,340,084 bytes 1.65x 00:01:38 (sr2)
    1,038,668,138 bytes 1.65x 00:01:18 (lzturbo 0.92 -53)
    1,037,037,999 bytes 1.66x 00:46:03 (lzturbo 0.92 -49)
    1,035,436,207 bytes 1.66x 00:15:39 (lzxq 0.2)
    1,026,947,413 bytes 1.67x 00:01:48 (lzturbo 0.92 -54)
    1,021,683,420 bytes 1.68x 00:25:33 (tornado 0.3 -12)
    1,020,399,529 bytes 1.68x 00:02:06 (lzturbo 0.92 -55)
    1,014,180,634 bytes 1.69x 00:02:29 (lzturbo 0.92 -56)
    1,011,026,143 bytes 1.70x 00:03:07 (lzturbo 0.92 -57)
    1,008,075,849 bytes 1.70x 00:06:42 (lzturbo 0.92 -5
    1,006,851,113 bytes 1.71x 00:00:42 (lzturbo 0.92 -51)
    0,997,638,404 bytes 1.72x 00:03:57 (lzpm 0.15 1)
    0,994,578,542 bytes 1.73x 00:04:30 (lzpm 0.15 2)
    0,991,632,789 bytes 1.73x 00:35:32 (lzpm 0.15 9)
    0,971,140,195 bytes 1.77x 00:04:30 (quad 1.12)
    0,968,567,016 bytes 1.77x 00:05:23 (quad 1.12 -x)
    0,967,833,740 bytes 1.78x 00:02:28 (sr3)
    0,967,358,643 bytes 1.78x 00:09:04 (mcomp 1.0 -ff)
    0,962,354,667 bytes 1.79x 00:46:49 (lzturbo 0.92 -59)
    0,961,221,337 bytes 1.79x 00:03:20 (hook 1.3 55)
    0,945,327,408 bytes 1.82x 00:02:43 (7za 4.57 7z 1)
    0,944,286,972 bytes 1.82x 00:04:38 (tarsaLZP)
    0,919,472,399 bytes 1.87x 00:04:05 (hook 1.3 12
    0,913,491,904 bytes 1.88x 00:00:50 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5)
    0,913,393,694 bytes 1.88x 00:02:31 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 bzip2 9)
    0,895,736,336 bytes 1.92x 00:04:25 (hook 1.3 256)
    0,882,578,283 bytes 1.95x 00:04:43 (hook 1.3 512)
    0,874,138,846 bytes 1.97x 00:03:49 (dark 0.51 default)
    0,855,554,775 bytes 2.01x 00:00:56 (lzc 0.08 1)
    0,816,201,716 bytes 2.11x 00:00:56 (lzc 0.08 2)
    0,809,421,573 bytes 2.12x 00:06:01 (7za 4.57 7z 5)
    0,808,861,777 bytes 2.12x 00:14:05 (mcomp 1.0 -f3f)
    0,783,953,063 bytes 2.19x 00:01:04 (lzc 0.08 3)
    0,783,800,100 bytes 2.19x 00:06:16 (arc 0.4 -m7)
    0,783,800,100 bytes 2.19x 00:06:15 (arc 0.4 -m7 -max)
    0,783,800,100 bytes 2.19x 00:06:12 (arc 0.4 -m4)
    0,783,800,100 bytes 2.19x 00:06:11 (arc 0.4 -m6)
    0,783,800,100 bytes 2.19x 00:06:10 (arc 0.4 -m5)
    0,776,339,871 bytes 2.21x 00:09:43 (7za 4.57 7z 9)
    0,770,661,181 bytes 2.23x 00:05:23 (hook 1.3 1024)
    0,764,514,710 bytes 2.25x 00:02:44 (stuffit 12.0.0.17 stuffitx 30)
    0,757,183,949 bytes 2.27x 00:01:16 (lzc 0.08 4)
    0,751,527,374 bytes 2.29x 00:07:40 (m99 max)
    0,749,218,466 bytes 2.29x 00:03:06 (arc 0.4 -m3)
    0,734,266,817 bytes 2.34x 00:01:34 (lzc 0.08 5)
    0,730,176,041 bytes 2.35x 00:01:11 (flashzip 0.03 1)
    0,729,775,327 bytes 2.35x 00:01:15 (flashzip 0.03 x 1)
    0,729,494,788 bytes 2.36x 00:01:01 (flashzip 0.02)
    0,724,637,948 bytes 2.37x 00:04:00 (m99 fast)
    0,723,218,689 bytes 2.38x 00:01:25 (flashzip 0.03 2)
    0,722,721,710 bytes 2.38x 00:01:29 (flashzip 0.03 x 2)
    0,713,736,576 bytes 2.41x 00:02:11 (lzc 0.08 6)
    0,713,719,141 bytes 2.41x 00:01:43 (flashzip 0.03 3)
    0,712,979,410 bytes 2.41x 00:01:53 (flashzip 0.03 x 3)
    0,708,213,048 bytes 2.43x 00:36:44 (lpaq1)
    0,701,639,936 bytes 2.45x 00:02:18 (flashzip 0.03 4)
    0,700,450,010 bytes 2.45x 00:02:38 (flashzip 0.03 x 4)
    0,694,998,886 bytes 2.47x 00:02:42 (lzc 0.08 7)
    0,686,941,819 bytes 2.50x 00:03:23 (flashzip 0.03 5)
    0,684,915,418 bytes 2.51x 00:04:06 (flashzip 0.03 x 5)
    0,682,298,054 bytes 2.52x 00:06:37 (hook 1.3 1280)
    0,677,572,453 bytes 2.54x 00:03:13 (lzc 0.08
    0,660,286,349 bytes 2.60x 00:03:43 (lzc 0.08 9)
    0,646,711,570 bytes 2.66x 00:04:13 (lzc 0.08 10)
    0,638,964,973 bytes 2.69x 00:01:42 (winturtle 1.6.0)
    0,604,287,885 bytes 2.84x 02:07:24 (slim23d)
    0,597,381,993 bytes 2.88x 00:19:34 (rzm 0.06b)
    0,596,482,301 bytes 2.88x 00:23:48 (rzm 0.07b)
    0,573,725,041 bytes 2.99x 00:37:32 (xwrt 3.2 -l14)
    0,566,356,066 bytes 3.03x 00:37:14 (lpaq8e)
    0,564,682,945 bytes 3.04x 00:02:11 (rings v1.2)
    0,562,771,445 bytes 3.05x 00:04:00 (rar 3.71 -3)
    0,559,835,421 bytes 3.07x 00:04:31 (rar 3.71 -4)
    0,557,364,808 bytes 3.08x 00:05:47 (rar 3.71 -5)
    0,543,106,065 bytes 3.16x 00:55:04 (paq9a -9)
    0,529,485,809 bytes 3.24x 00:15:32 (uharc 0.6a -m1)
    0,528,675,652 bytes 3.25x 00:16:47 (uharc 0.6a -m2)
    0,528,063,193 bytes 3.25x 00:18:05 (uharc 0.6a -m3)
    0,502,339,962 bytes 3.42x 00:49:24 (ppmonstr default)
    0,501,036,338 bytes 3.43x 00:23:59 (uharc 0.6a -mx)
    0,479,032,436 bytes 3.59x 00:01:53 (uharc 0.6a -mz)
    0,369,350,651 bytes 4.65x 00:04:22 (winace 2.69 super fast)
    0,368,287,422 bytes 4.67x 00:07:19 (sbc 0.97 -m3)
    0,359,996,375 bytes 4.77x 00:05:07 (winace 2.69 fast)
    0,356,510,003 bytes 4.82x 00:12:08 (ccm 1.3 0)
    0,353,541,645 bytes 4.86x 00:12:38 (ccm 1.3 7)
    0,347,044,997 bytes 4.95x 00:13:40 (ccmx 1.3 0)
    0,345,749,131 bytes 4.97x 00:08:04 (winace 2.69 normal)
    0,338,990,427 bytes 5.07x 00:11:16 (winace 2.69 good)
    0,338,315,921 bytes 5.08x 00:14:44 (ccmx 1.3 7)
    0,333,938,343 bytes 5.15x 00:19:17 (winace 2.69 maximum)
    0,328,710,164 bytes 5.23x 00:09:21 (pim 2.10)
    0,327,835,015 bytes 5.24x 00:04:15 (sbc 0.97 -m2)
    0,327,235,430 bytes 5.25x 00:03:48 (sbc 0.97 -m1)

    skipped to long time (bbb 1280)
    out of memory (durilca light 0.5 default)
    crash (cmm4 0.0)

  24. #54
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Moscow
    Posts
    239
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 3 Times in 1 Post
    P.F. filtered:
    Code:
    1,320,460,586 bytes 1.30x 00:00:17 (thor 0.96 e1) 
    1,239,335,736 bytes 1.39x 00:00:19 (thor 0.96 e2) 
    1,225,780,905 bytes 1.40x 00:00:21 (lzturbo 0.92 -22) 
    1,170,670,336 bytes 1.47x 00:00:23 (lzturbo 0.92 -42) 
    1,006,851,113 bytes 1.71x 00:00:42 (lzturbo 0.92 -51) 
    0,913,491,904 bytes 1.88x 00:00:50 (7za 4.57 bzip2 5) 
    0,816,201,716 bytes 2.11x 00:00:56 (lzc 0.08 2) 
    0,729,494,788 bytes 2.36x 00:01:01 (flashzip 0.02) 
    0,723,218,689 bytes 2.38x 00:01:25 (flashzip 0.03 2) 
    0,722,721,710 bytes 2.38x 00:01:29 (flashzip 0.03 x 2) 
    0,638,964,973 bytes 2.69x 00:01:42 (winturtle 1.6.0) 
    0,479,032,436 bytes 3.59x 00:01:53 (uharc 0.6a -mz) 
    0,327,235,430 bytes 5.25x 00:03:48 (sbc 0.97 -m1)
    Strange results for FreeArc. Can you try bmf -f -s, bmfc and grzip -m1 also?

  25. #55
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by nimdamsk
    Can you try bmf -f -s, bmfc and grzip -m1 also?
    794,894,757 bytes 00:04:03 (grzipii 0.2.4 -m3)
    788,964,760 bytes 00:04:35 (grzipii 0.2.4 -m1)
    757,573,927 bytes 00:02:02 (grzipii 0.2.4 -m4)
    751,412,570 bytes 00:02:37 (grzipii 0.2.4 -m2)
    532,403,700 bytes 00:0x:xx (adobe photoshop elements 5.02 png)

    out of memory (adobe photoshop elements 5.02 jp2)
    out of memory (bmf 1.1 -f -s)
    out of memory (bmfc 2.0)

  26. #56
    Programmer
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    420
    Thanks
    28
    Thanked 163 Times in 18 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Christian
    Can you please use RZM 0.07e instead of 0.07b. Actually, 0.07b was removed for good a few minutes after its release.
    Thanks again.

  27. #57
    Programmer Bulat Ziganshin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Uzbekistan
    Posts
    4,593
    Thanks
    801
    Thanked 698 Times in 378 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by nimdamsk
    Strange results for FreeArc
    -m4..-m9 methods use MM filter + grzip to conpress BMPs, so results are the same. -m3 use MM+grzip with faster grzip setting which usually gives less comrpression (but not in this case)


    Sportman, please try http://dimin.m6.net/software/geojasp...sper_win32.zip for jpeg-2000 compression. tif2jp2.bat should suffice

  28. #58
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Bulat Ziganshin
    please try http://dimin.m6.net/software/geojasp...sper_win32.zip for jpeg-2000 compression. tif2jp2.bat should suffice
    I tried but get message "abnormal program termination".

    Some other results:

    1,718,179,344 bytes 00:0x:xx (adobe photoshop elements 5.02 tiff uncompressed)
    0,947,668,532 bytes 00:30:41 (bee 0.7.9 -m1)
    0,935,901,371 bytes 00:33:50 (bee 0.7.9 -m2)
    0,939,160,817 bytes 00:34:36 (bee 0.7.9 -m3)
    0,774,160,817 bytes 00:24:02 (bwtzip)
    0,637,578,964 bytes 00:0x:xx (adobe photoshop elements 5.02 tiff lzw)
    0,477,068,148 bytes 00:0x:xx (adobe photoshop elements 5.02 tiff zip)

  29. #59
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    1,040
    Thanks
    104
    Thanked 420 Times in 293 Posts
    Finally I managed to convert the big BMP image to lossless jpeg-2000 with Kakadu software (32-bit multithreaded):

    0,414,541,434 bytes 00:00:23 (kdu compress 6.0 jp2 lossless)

  30. #60
    Programmer Bulat Ziganshin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Uzbekistan
    Posts
    4,593
    Thanks
    801
    Thanked 698 Times in 378 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Sportman
    For test 8 I scanned a full color glossy cover page
    please try freearc with forced MM detection: -m=mm:3*8+grzip:l

Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Compression and speed
    By Wladmir in forum Data Compression
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 25th April 2010, 13:15
  2. MONSTER OF COMPRESSION - New Benchmark
    By LovePimple in forum Data Compression
    Replies: 225
    Last Post: 23rd December 2009, 11:57
  3. GCC 4.4 and compression speed
    By Hahobas in forum Data Compression
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: 5th March 2009, 18:31
  4. New benchmark for generic compression
    By Matt Mahoney in forum Data Compression
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 29th December 2008, 09:20
  5. Synthetic compression benchmark
    By giorgiotani in forum Forum Archive
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 3rd March 2008, 12:14

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •